@wissox
Since you were kind enough to respond in some detail, I will try to keep the volley going amicably.
"…we beat Duke and Kentucky regularly lately!"
You didn't supply evidence the way you ask me to, but I'm cool. Let's assume you're right.
Lately, of course does not change what went on before, right? It only refers to lately, so it really serves to highlight that the origins of the dissatisfaction did not necessarily start lately. Lately Villa-refereea appeared to take over EST serve in the post season from Duke and UK, when Duke and UK went on their mysteriously extreme OAD diets shedding down from 9-10 on a team to 4-6 on a team, while KU has cut down from a slim 3 to a near starvation 1.
But let's reduce the ethers further here.
Did we beat Kentucky with its 6 OAD stack in 2012 for the championship, when we had no OADs? No.
Did we beat Kentucky with its 10 OAD stack in 2015 (or whatever years they had the long stacks)? No.
Did we beat Duke with its 9 OAD stack in 2015? Not sure if we even played them, so let's say either no, or we did not play them, or if we did they were 'nicked up" at the time.
Have we beaten Duke in pre conference after their long stack teams were reduced to medium stack teams and we had the remnant of short stack (3 OADs)? Yes.
Have we beaten UK in pre conference, when Cal's long stacks were reduced to a medium stack (4-6 OADs) and we had the remnant of a short stack (3 one time OADs)? Yes.
Have we beaten Duke this season with a short stack and Coach K apparently sick, while we have 1 OAD and a bunch of 3 and 4 stars? Yes.
Have we beaten Cal with a medium stack in pre conference, while we have 1 OAD and a bunch of 3 and 4 starts? Yes.
Does any of this matter? Well, it at least suggests that Self can sometimes beat Coach K and Cal, if Self has 3/4, or 2/3s, or half, or a third, or a 1/4 of the OAD talent that those coaches have, when it is pre conference season, and when apparently asymmetric seeding and apparently asymmetric refereeing of the kind that appearances suggest (at least to me and perhaps to some others) occur in the March Carney, are not appearing to occur so egregiously during pre-conference season.
It also raises a question: why DOES KU have to compete with elite EST programs at an OAD disadvantage in total numbers of OADs? And a 5 star disadvantage in total numbers of 5-stars?
Here is your explanation: "Could it be, just asking, could it be that kids see Duke and UK playing on the final weekend a little more regularly than KU and decide they want that as well?"
Zero evidence. Nada. Zippo. Just a question.
But that's okay. I'm not strident about lack of evidence, when we are just brainstorming hypotheses here, and not talking theories.
Here is my answer: Because complexity is a female dog, ANYTHING IS POSSIBLE. An alien fart on the nearest exo planet COULD have caused OADs to favor Duke over KU by as many as 9 to 3, or UK by as many as 10 to 3, or in 2012 that same alien fart on the nearest exo planet COULD have caused OADs to favor UK over KU 6 to 0.
To reiterate: because of complexity, ANYTHING IS POSSIBLE.
But do you seriously think your question hints at the highest probability of why OADs favor Duke and UK over KU at such anomalous and varying levels, seemingly barely correlated to differences in NCAA tourney performances? I just can't quite find that the most PROBABLE hypothesis yet, much less view it as a proven theory.
And now to your final point...
"I’ll believe your tournament engineering theory when you give me evidence."
I will too, whether you, or I, or someone else provides it.
As I try to remind readers here, including you, I know of NO "theory" about tournament engineering. Regardless of how you may wish to use the word theory, "Theory" as I use it is a proven hypothesis. Hypothesis, as I use it, is an explanation posited to start inquiry into an apparent phenomenon. Its utility is in focusing inquiry and directing collection of evidence. It is not a conclusion. It could easily be wrong. It probably will be wrong to some degree, or other. It is a starting point. To my knowledge, no one has proven a theory of tournament engineering. I know I have not. I have only posed a hypothesis of tournament engineering, as a possible point of beginning inquiry to order the collection of evidence to try to explain the appearance (at least to me and maybe a few others) in recent years of the tournament's seeding and refereeing looking less than symmetric at times. I don't suspect any illegal conspiracy, or any kind of illegality involved. March Madness just appears to look more and more like professional wrestling and professional prize fighting to mois. Those are both legal sports in my understanding. It could be a complete coincidence that it appears this way. Or it could be engineering of the tournament based on entertainment values coniciding with those sports. I don't know which it is. I only know the NCAA tourney just doesn't appear the way it used to appear to me. Maybe it is because I am getting old? Maybe its because of alien mind control from reptilians living amongst us? Or maybe its because of economic pressures and strategic dynamics of the myriad participants in the college basketball industry? Or maybe I'm misperceiving? I thought about it some and decided to take a first cut at possible explanation of tournament engineering underpinned by economic pressures and strategic dynamics. You don't find it persuasive, as I don't find your implied hypothesis that OADs are drawn like flies to Duke and UK simply because you believe Duke and UK may survive a little later in the tourney. You need to bring me some evidence on that.
I'll even add that if you bring me conclusive evidence of some other form of tournament engineering than what I propose, then I will believe your theory of another form of tournament engineering.
And I won't stop there.
I'll add that if you posit a hypothesis that the March Madness is completely symmetric in seeding and refereeing, and bring me conclusive evidence of it being so, then I will believe your theory that March Madness is completely symmetric in seeding and refereeing, despite it appearing something like a March Carney to me, then I will accept your hypothesis as proven.
Just bring me conclusive evidence, if you want me to accept one of your hypotheses as a theory; that's all I ask.
I'm easy to persuade with conclusive evidence. And I think most board rats are.
Until you bring it, or I do, I guess I will just have to keep laboring along with my hypothesis and keep trying to find evidence and support, refute, or revise it.
Rock Chalk!