Truths, damned truths, and more statistics
PHOF.
What you did here is what QA is supposed to do: HELP US FIND DRIVERS WITHIN DYNAMICS OF GAMES (OR PROCESSES) OPERATING WITH RULES, INCENTIVES. OPTIONS, THAT HAVE GENERATED EQUILIBRIUM STRATEGIES, AMIDST EMERGING COMPLEXITY WHILST TIME TO PLAY DIMINISHES.
In QA we look backward to find drivers and constraints.
Then we look forward with those drivers into changing (or unchanging) constraints.
Then we design solutions (teams) tailored to those drivers to operate efficiently within those constraints.
Then we measure degree of fit with context and driver efficiency in operation and production.
Then we iterate till we get the degree of fit and driver efficiency in "satisficing" trade off.
Then we win.
Most of the time.
Random error (error beyond our ability to anticipate and/or measure and control for) is so far inextinguishable amidst complexity.
Next: I don't want anyone to misread your comment about Jesse almost lying. Lying to me connotes and denotes intent to deceive and misrepresent. What Jesse did was leave a his best intended effort at a quantitative bread crumb trail that enabled you to follow down it and take an unfitting oversimplification of his out of his conclusion.
This is exactly what is supposed to happen science and QA.
Science, especially the QA end of it, is (or should be) about not having to reinvent wheels, unless they don't work.
What you did is necessarily an outgrowth of the legacy of Jesse's and HEM's thinking on this issue.
In science, to be wrong understandably is the next best thing to being right understandably. And all rightness is science is really just sufficient degree of fit with context for now.
Lack of understanding of how we did what we did is the great obstacle slowing all human development to a crawl. What we don't know we don't know makes us wholly dependent on dumb luck for fitting development. Getting to the point of knowing what we don't know is the beginning of knowledge driven development. Basketball needs knowledge driven development. You and Jesse are BOTH contributing.
I know you know what I am talking about here, but I have learned over the years that there are many persons that want to be a part of the scientific endeavor that simply need a friendly hand offered in the form of a brief introduction in this regard. So consider this part not for you.
Science and scientific progress are fundamentally collaborative and cooperative. Science is NOT a game of winning but of fitting. Science occurs in a conflicted and competitive context. Conflicted competitors fund it. Scientists themselves can become conflicted competitors, because they are chasing scarce resources to do their work. But these are the great contextual impediments to science that scientists must survive and negotiate in order to do the fundamentally collaborative work that they do.
Once one begins to understand that all science is built on the thought work of what has come before; that one owes a profound debt to the most ill-fitting of prior solutions in science, so long as they were proposed coherently and explicitly enough to be found to be have inadequate fit to remain useful later by one's self, or one's colleagues, then one can become a better scientist/thinker by shedding scales of ego from one's eyes and scientific mind. Scientists and ballers and board rats need some swagger, but not too much. :-)
Jesse oversimplified in a way that helped you to find a more fitting solution.
Without him, and HEM, you might not have thought to explain it; this is one of the most curious and counter intuitive aspects of science to non scientists.
Most scientific discoveries arise from preceding inadequate/incomplete systematic explanations.
And most scientific discoveries have within them the seeds of inadequacy and incompleteness that will trigger the next advance, when need arises.
Science desperately needs ill-fitting, incomplete, inadequate but coherent solutions. It needs as many as possible. Every inadequate, incomplete, but coherent solution increases our odds of finding a more adequate, more complete solution. Jordan had to miss a lot of shots to make the ones he needed to win games.
Some persons that would love science if only they could get over the inhibition of being wrong by seeing that it is okay to be wrong, if you are coherently wrong; i.e., if you are systematic enough in your approach for someone to learn from your work and improve upon it, sometimes benefit from the following metaphor from my own life.
Once I went out for a long walk in a wilderness area with a friend and got lost. We had no map. No compass. We were so engrossed in an intellectual conversation that we forgot to pay attention to what paths we were taking. And I was so dazzled by the beauty of the place that whenever I did look around I still paid no attention to the route we had hiked. When we decided we had solved the problems of the world enough, we realized we were hopelessly lost. We did not know how we had gotten to where we had gotten, much less how to get where else we might have wanted to go. Our walk was an incoherent solution to get to a destination. We got to it, but had no clue how. A person who was also lost stopped and asked us how to get back. We could not help him. Because we did not understand what we had done, we were at the mercy of dumb luck to undo it. Mercifully, we were shortly lucky and found someone with enough sense to have kept track of where they had been going. The kind person lead us part of the way back then grew uncertain about which fork in the trail to take at a certain point. Fortunately, the other lost person that was walking with us recalled this part of the trail clearly. We followed that trail back. Deliverance was a collaborative effort. I also learned never to forget my surveying rules for survival I had learned when I was a young man. Never go anywhere in a wilderness that you cannot retrace by known steps. If you wish to lose yourself in thought, do so in a known location. You wish to explore, always make a mental map back.
All science and QA are are reproducible maps of how we got where we are.
Again, this bit of didacticism has not been meant for you.
Regarding your counsel that HEM amend "free your mind" to "do the maths" I would amend you to "do both." And I could not possibly have amended it thusly without both of you.
The only human driven things as beautiful as science and QA are games, navigation/surveying, arts and love.
With these things, humans relentlessly push back the darkness they are born into.
Without them, they flounder.
The game needs science and QA.
You have brought some.
Joe Dooley obviously was a QA guy Self has yet to find a replacement for.
Rock Chalk!
P.S.: Epigrams and rules are useful, but like found drivers and verified theories, they typically are incomplete, regardless of whether or not they may also be subject too a few exceptions. When working with anything from hunches, to QA derived drivers, to verified empirical facts and theories, I like to remember a marvelous thing Frank Lloyd Wright once said, as an aging genius, when he found himself ass deep in increasingly doctrinaire modernist architects. These doctrinaire modernists were fond of spouting a rule of Mies van der Roe's: "Less is more." Wright said: "Less is more, only if more is no good." I don't really know why I have added this post script, but it seemed worth passing on.